texas Date: 09-18-2025

Top 14 Rated Jeweler in Tyler, TX (part 2)

Jewelry StoresAddress
1Jim’s Jewelers2009 Old Troup Hwy, Tyler, TX 75701
2Icing4601 S Broadway Ave Suite D06C, Tyler, TX 75703
3Crystal Rock Shop2136 Roy Rd, Tyler, TX 75707
4South Broadway Jewelers4921 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703
5Jared Jewelers4574 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703
6Gold, Silver & Vintage Treasures1908 W Erwin St, Tyler, TX 75702
7Murphey the Jeweler4921 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703
8James Avery Artisan Jewelry4601 S Broadway Ave #J01A, Tyler, TX 75703
9Gods Money Gold & Silver1898 W Cumberland Rd Suite 103, Tyler, TX 75703
10KAY Jewelers4601 S Broadway Ave Space F05A, Tyler, TX 75703
11Sterling Grace Jewelry4720 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703
12FUEGO / ATTIC SALT4601 S Broadway Ave Space #G05A, Tyler, TX 75703
13COACH4601 S Broadway Ave Space C05, Tyler, TX 75703
14Susan Robinson Jewelry5779 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703

1.Jim’s Jewelers

Address: 2009 Old Troup Hwy, Tyler, TX 75701

(371) user ratings total:

Allana Coleman Lynn at Jim’s Jewelers assisted us with modifications to a couple men’s rings and sized our fingers. The whole staff was welcoming and friendly. We received our rings very quickly and the work was IMPRESSIVE! They also have a wide selection of rings etc. I highly recommend Jim’s Jewelers for all your needs.
5 /5

2.Icing

Address: 4601 S Broadway Ave Suite D06C, Tyler, TX 75703

(36) user ratings total:

Layla Johnson My family and I were in here about 20 minutes ago, at around 8pm. Normally we have a decent experience, however this time was terrible. There was an employee by the name of Natalee. We went to go checkout, and we stood at the register, and we were some of the only ones in the store. She was nowhere to be found. My sister asked where she was, I thought she was helping another customer, but when those two people left, I was confused. At this point, we had been waiting about 8 minutes at the register at this point. I walked the whole store and discovered we were the only ones in there. I called the store, and the phone rang for a few minutes before Natalee came out from the back room, acting like everything was normal. I cant speak as to what she was doing back there obviously, or how long she had even been back there, but to leave the store unattended for any amount of time is unacceptable.
1 /5

3.Crystal Rock Shop

Address: 2136 Roy Rd, Tyler, TX 75707

(357) user ratings total:

Jaide Reynolds I did a Google search for Tarot Cards. I was directed to a couple of chain stores, which I had already been to with no success as their selections were meager, and this shop which was only open on Fridays and Saturdays. Its in a residential area, so I was expecting something simple and quaint. THIS PLACE IS AMAZING! They have a large selection of raw stones for $10 a pound outside and an even larger selection of polished crystals and minerals inside! The selection of Tarot Cards was absolutely perfect because I immediately found the deck I was looking for. They have a surprisingly large selection of metaphysical tools for all stages of your spiritual journey inside as well. I could barely drag myself out of this place, but I had laundry in at a laundromat. The staff was over-the-top friendly and helpful. They made helpful and informative suggestions based upon my conversational feedback. They really listened and paid attention. It was truly an immersive and customized experience for me.
5 /5

4.South Broadway Jewelers

Address: 4921 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703

(34) user ratings total:

Jennifer Ginger was so nice and helpful. She really listened to what we wanted and made our dream rings come true. If there was an option to give this jeweler more stars I would.
5 /5

5.Jared Jewelers

Address: 4574 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703

(325) user ratings total:

Amber Haynes We had the best experience and so much fun picking out our wedding bands at Jared Jewelers! Autumn Dotson helped make it an expensive we will never forget! Thank you Autumn and the amazing staff at Jared!! WE WILL BE BACK!
5 /5

6.Gold, Silver & Vintage Treasures

Address: 1908 W Erwin St, Tyler, TX 75702

(319) user ratings total:

david rich Brought back childhood memories. Got told about this place by competition. The owner has built an awesome place. Very family oriented. Ive never left thinking I got ripped off. On the contrary I feel I got over on them lol. Check this place out. Has a little bit for everyone
5 /5

7.Murphey the Jeweler

Address: 4921 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703

(28) user ratings total:

Timothy Walding Stopped in to find some spring bars and to ask about a repair on a ring. Lady acted like she did not want to be bothered helping me. I purchased from them before but no more. It was not like the store was busy, there was only 1 other customer besides me in the store. It is amazing how kindness and customer service is a thing of the past.
2 /5

8.James Avery Artisan Jewelry

Address: 4601 S Broadway Ave #J01A, Tyler, TX 75703

images James Avery Artisan Jewelry

(265) user ratings total:

Alejandro S I’ve been shopping at James Avery for over a decade, choosing it for special occasion gifts because of the consistently excellent customer service and respect I’ve always received. Today was especially memorable as I had the pleasure of meeting the store manager, Nathan “Nate.” Without going into the details of the issue, I can say that Nate went above and beyond—returning my call promptly and resolving my concern with professionalism and care. He was kind, patient, and understanding, truly embodying the qualities of an outstanding store manager. Thank you, Nate, and the entire James Avery team, for continuing to provide such exceptional service.
5 /5

9.Gods Money Gold & Silver

Address: 1898 W Cumberland Rd Suite 103, Tyler, TX 75703

(26) user ratings total:

Ruth Fowlkes When it comes to trusting someone to sell my old gold and silver jewelry to, God’s Money is the only place I trust! I cringe thinking of all the money I lost selling my jewelry to pawn shops over the years! Check them out! You won’t be disappointed!!! Such a wonderful family and friendly business!
5 /5

10.KAY Jewelers

Address: 4601 S Broadway Ave Space F05A, Tyler, TX 75703

(255) user ratings total:

Kenneth Work My wife had been in contact with Deb about a bracelet she had her eye on. Deb emailed me a link so I could check it out and easily schedule a time to come in. When we arrived, Deb was assisting another customer, but the manager stepped in right away and helped us without missing a beat. The customer service at Kay’s is truly unmatched, friendly, efficient, and thoughtful. I was also pleasantly surprised to receive a Memorial Day discount! Overall, a fantastic experience from start to finish.
5 /5

11.Sterling Grace Jewelry

Address: 4720 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703

(250) user ratings total:

Kayla Price The staffs exceptional friendliness made the ear-piercing experience for my daughter and her best friend a truly wonderful and tear-free one.
5 /5

12.FUEGO / ATTIC SALT

Address: 4601 S Broadway Ave Space #G05A, Tyler, TX 75703

(25) user ratings total:

Paige They have a lot to choose from, especially jewelry. My daughter loves to buy her earrings from here, and they usually have some type of deal going on. I like to look at their unique assortment of items. For instance, I regret not buying the bar of soap they had that was labeled to be scented like "Beyonces breathe". They keep Gudatama in stock...I mean who wouldnt think a lazy egg yolk with a butt isnt cute? They have everything you didnt know you needed.
5 /5

13.COACH

Address: 4601 S Broadway Ave Space C05, Tyler, TX 75703

(25) user ratings total:

Jasmin I had such a good experience with my friends! I don’t remember their names but everyone was so kind and patient with us, letting us look at every bag we were interested in and monogramming with care. I would rather go to the Tyler location than Houston or Dallas. I can’t wait for my next purchase :)
5 /5

14.Susan Robinson Jewelry

Address: 5779 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75703

(249) user ratings total:

Shevawn Beltz Susan Robinson has made a customer for life. I had a diamond fall out of my wedding ring and was looking for a place with in-house repair. It’s an older ring and knew it wouldn’t be an easy fix. Being new to the Tyler area and particularly careful about who would handle my ring with the utmost care, this team and staff immediately put me at ease. Matt, the technician is a gem on this earth! His skills and attention to detail is beyond exceptional. Getting my ring back, took my breath away and brought me to tears. It was brought back to its original form and looked better than the day I received it. They’re personable, compassionate and experts in their field. I’ll forever be grateful for the wonderful staff at Susan Robinson.
5 /5