texas Date: 08-31-2025

19 Best Insurance Services in Tyler, TX

AgentcyAddress
1Tom Sorrels Insurance Agency1313 S Vine Ave, Tyler, TX 75701
2Higginbotham - Tyler6101 S Broadway Ave Suite 430, Tyler, TX 75703
3Farmers Insurance - Karl Benner1519 E 5th St, Tyler, TX 75701
4Leavitt Group Texas Select113 Shelley Dr, Tyler, TX 75701
5Reliable Life Insurance Co3320 Old Troup Hwy # 220, Tyler, TX 75701
6The Insurance Shop4711 Old Bullard Rd, Tyler, TX 75703
7Day One Insurance Group: Allstate Insurance320 S Broadway Ave #100, Tyler, TX 75702
8Neighbors Insurance Agency, LLC102 N College Ave # 616, Tyler, TX 75702
9Texas Wide Insurance504 E Front St, Tyler, TX 75702
10Direct Auto Insurance4205 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75701
11Standard Insurance Agency1510 E SE Loop 323, Tyler, TX 75701
12AMIGOS INSURANCE LLC317 N Beckham Ave, Tyler, TX 75702
13Community Insurance1015 W Front St, Tyler, TX 75702
14Nicholson Insurance Group LLC16347 Hwy 155 S, Tyler, TX 75703
15Ai United Insurance109 N Beckham Ave, Tyler, TX 75702
16Weserv Insurance & Financial Services LLC1820 Shiloh Rd UNIT 1501, Tyler, TX 75703
17Claeys Group Insurance Services1118 S Wall Ave, Tyler, TX 75701
18ABC Insurance Agencies4205 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75701
19Gibb Agency Insurance13381 State Hwy 155, Tyler, TX 75703

1.Tom Sorrels Insurance Agency

Address: 1313 S Vine Ave, Tyler, TX 75701

(40) Clients Are Saying about:

Alesha Folsom Ive done business with this agency for over 20 years. They always try to find me the lowest price with the best coverage. Tom Sorrells and his daughter Leslie are great people. They always have a smile, and Im treated like family. I cant ask for more than that.
5 /5
A Z (Zan) Wow ! This place was very diligent. The teller named Cindy was friendly and carefree !! I purchased my bonded titles for less than $200 !
5 /5

2.Higginbotham - Tyler

Address: 6101 S Broadway Ave Suite 430, Tyler, TX 75703

(4) Clients Are Saying about:

Kay Bateman Friendly, helpful and efficient! I am very satisfied with their communication.
5 /5
Glenda Jerger I wasnt there. I was at Smart Choice Clinic. Higginbotham isnt there anymore.
1 /5

3.Farmers Insurance - Karl Benner

Address: 1519 E 5th St, Tyler, TX 75701

4.Leavitt Group Texas Select

Address: 113 Shelley Dr, Tyler, TX 75701

(39) Clients Are Saying about:

Noah McIntyre Kevin Tweedell has been my insurance agent for the past two years, and he has never disappointed! I recently needed to get my insurance changed over quickly with my upcoming marriage and home purchase. Once again, Kevin and Leavitt Select were there and ready at a moments notice to make everything happen! They are easy to work with, and I have zero complaints. 5 stars, highly recommend!
5 /5
Zach Ive used them since 2015 and its only got better! Kevins always keeping in touch with rate updates and is really personable.
5 /5

5.Reliable Life Insurance Co

Address: 3320 Old Troup Hwy # 220, Tyler, TX 75701

(37) Clients Are Saying about:

Mercedes Bush "Wow, I had such a fantastic experience with the Jocelyn. Her knowledge of life insurance policies and their full benefits was truly impressive. She took the time to patiently explain everything to me and answered all my questions….. And I had a million of them. She made me feel extremely comfortable and confident in my decision. I highly recommend her if youre looking for someone who is knowledgeable. Thank you Jocelyn for the great service!"
5 /5
Ronta Wooten They are nice people and they help u anyway they can. Rod Caesar an very nice guy and does his best to give u the best service. Also Jocelyn Marshall is also a good agent shes friendly very helpful and also does her best to get u what u need. All around these are good people.
5 /5

6.The Insurance Shop

Address: 4711 Old Bullard Rd, Tyler, TX 75703

(37) Clients Are Saying about:

jimmy simmons Best insurance company around. Friendly and helpful. Will be there for you.find the best policy for you not try to sell you whats best for them. Great service great people great products and great prices.
5 /5
Jessica Prather They have the best prices, best communication, and the best staff! So very grateful for all they’ve done for keeping me and my family covered.
5 /5

7.Day One Insurance Group: Allstate Insurance

Address: 320 S Broadway Ave #100, Tyler, TX 75702

images Day One Insurance Group: Allstate Insurance

(355) Clients Are Saying about:

edgar cerrillo Ive only been a homeowner for a couple of years so dealing with home insurance and understanding it has been a stress in itself. I contacted Dillon myrick and where many other fell short he succeeded. He went above and beyond when it comes to customer service. He answered every question I had and even offered sound advice and was able to give me multiple options where I had trouble even getting just one quote from multiple other places. He was prompt, polite and just seemed eager and happy to help in any way. I didnt feel any kind of pressure to settle for just any quote with him and on top of that I got greater coverage for my home for over 1k less.
5 /5
Michael Quinn Day one insurance group is where its at!! A special shout out to the agent that hooked me up! (Hugo Sanchez). Hugo was very helpful and went out of his way to start my policy earlier then I anticipated. ((( ON TOP OF SAVING ME $133 A MONTH))) with a better policy, and a small renters policy. Thank you a million day one! I will recommend you to anyone thatll listen.
5 /5

8.Neighbors Insurance Agency, LLC

Address: 102 N College Ave # 616, Tyler, TX 75702

(35) Clients Are Saying about:

Dalamar Hobbs Called on Max at Guardian completely out of the blue, absolutely last minute, mired in drama and controversy...to meet us at a local nursing home and have some critical paperwork notarized. Max arrived within the half hour, hovered in the background, and was the perfect gentleman. He did his work, upset no one, performed perfectly, and melted away like he was never there. The price was more than reasonable, and his service was impeccable. Will certainly use this service again!
5 /5
Damon Logue I wanted to take a moment to share my recent experience with Max from Guardian Insurance. During our conversation about coverage options, Max exhibited exceptional professionalism and knowledge. He took the time to thoroughly explain all the policies and what they covered, leaving me feeling confident in my decisions. I was truly impressed by Maxs expertise and customer service skills. Based on my positive interaction with him, I wholeheartedly recommend both Max and Guardian Insurance to anyone in need of reliable coverage and outstanding support. Thank you for providing such outstanding service, and I look forward to continuing my relationship with Guardian Insurance. Warm regards, Damon Logue!
5 /5

9.Texas Wide Insurance

Address: 504 E Front St, Tyler, TX 75702

(35) Clients Are Saying about:

Gerardo Hernandez I want to thank Erika de Pinos for her excellent customer service, her charisma, and her determination to solve my problem and find the best option and coverage for my needs. Thank you so much, and blessings to you and your entire family.
5 /5
Brice Krueger Cheapest insurance Ive found and the staff is wonderful. I would definitely recommend this company.
5 /5

10.Direct Auto Insurance

Address: 4205 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75701

(34) Clients Are Saying about:

Delesa Bradley Ashlynn was excellent and made the process so easy ! We will definitely recommend her
5 /5
Brandon Grimes So far it hasn’t been great… first I was offered a policy for $94 stating up but the system froze right as you guys deducted the $ from my bank account but didn’t give me a policy… that $94 is still pending in my account and I had to rebuy insurance from you wich raised almost $35 all in the matter of a couple hours… I will definitely be exploring other options when it comes time to renew
1 /5

11.Standard Insurance Agency

Address: 1510 E SE Loop 323, Tyler, TX 75701

(34) Clients Are Saying about:

J I was with this company for F I V E years , they dropped me because my car mileage has high and tried to lie and say it was because I had hail damage and they no longer cover hail damage. I will never do business with this company again . It’s been a head ache gaining to switch companies again after five years . Horrible business.
1 /5
Keysha Reeves I was at work one day and mentioned I needed to search for better car insurance .My coworker referred me to Standard Insurance. I couldnt believe the quote! Ive been with them over a year now. Great staff! Thank you Standard Insurance team, and Ms. Cheri Scott!
5 /5

12.AMIGOS INSURANCE LLC

Address: 317 N Beckham Ave, Tyler, TX 75702

(34) Clients Are Saying about:

Sara Elizabeth Sallee She’s extremely caring, always helpful! Great experience overall.
5 /5
Francisco Pedraza Affordable great customer service
5 /5

13.Community Insurance

Address: 1015 W Front St, Tyler, TX 75702

(32) Clients Are Saying about:

Tosha Street Professional, informative, HONEST, and very up-front direct communication. The entire staff will assist in any manner in which they can and this is EVERYTIME Ive ever stopped by.Great people to interact and do business with.
5 /5
lacy roberts I just went and got insurance with them. It was the easiest and fastest Ive ever seen. Terrell is amazing. I would recommend everyone try them.
5 /5

14.Nicholson Insurance Group LLC

Address: 16347 Hwy 155 S, Tyler, TX 75703

images Nicholson Insurance Group LLC

(30) Clients Are Saying about:

Dr. J. Christopher Hubert My experience with Nicholson Insurance has been excellent!! Kent worked hard to put together a coverage plan that was efficient for my specific needs. I saved over $3500/ year and I have much more confidence and understanding about my policy.
5 /5
Justin Staples Kent is the best insurance agent I have ever dealt with. He seems to know just about everything dealing with insurance. I always have 20 questions and he is very patient in answering them! He will definitely make sure you get the best deal. We have our regular cars, our antique pickup, motorcycle and camper all listed with him.
5 /5

15.Ai United Insurance

Address: 109 N Beckham Ave, Tyler, TX 75702

(293) Clients Are Saying about:

Bernardo Garcia Extremely nice, she helped me a lot & was very patient. Cant wait to recommend!
5 /5
Victor zendejas Ashley was very helpful and her service was really good and she managed to get me a really good price on my insurance
5 /5

16.Weserv Insurance & Financial Services LLC

Address: 1820 Shiloh Rd UNIT 1501, Tyler, TX 75703

(29) Clients Are Saying about:

Rizwan Cool I had a great experience with Weserv Insurance & Financial Services LLC. They provided excellent customer service and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. The team was professional, knowledgeable, and helped me find the right coverage for my needs. Thank you so much for your outstanding service—I truly appreciate it! Highly recommended!
5 /5
Ryan Wagle I have worked with Rosie and Weserve for the last 6 years. They are very good at what they do. They are helping me and my family for the health insurance needs and recently my autos and home as well. They do other real state related services as well but I have not used other perks. They do my renewals on time and with competitive pricing.
4 /5

17.Claeys Group Insurance Services

Address: 1118 S Wall Ave, Tyler, TX 75701

(280) Clients Are Saying about:

Elim Wells My wife and I, both in our senior years, were trying to find the right medical insurance that fit our needs and budget. Thats when we found John Claeys through an online search, and were so grateful we did! John took the time to listen carefully to our concerns, explained all the options in simple, easy-to-understand terms, and guided us through the entire process without any pressure or sales tactics. He was incredibly knowledgeable about plans tailored for seniors, including coverage for prescriptions, doctor visits, and potential hospital stays. Thanks to his expertise, we ended up with a policy that gives us peace of mind and saves us money. Johns patience and genuine care made what could have been a stressful experience feel straightforward and reassuring. If youre a senior looking for medical insurance advice, I highly recommend John Claeys—hes a true professional who puts his clients first! Thank you, John!
5 /5
Clara Scott Mr.Claeys is a very nice, dependable, and intelligent man. He makes sure you understands everything in detail and answers any and all your questions with so much patience. He really goes above and beyond with his customers. He even checked to make sure my physician’s was in network with the insurance plan I chose. I was very impressed and appreciative to him. Thank you John Claeys!!
5 /5

18.ABC Insurance Agencies

Address: 4205 S Broadway Ave, Tyler, TX 75701

(28) Clients Are Saying about:

Fayetta Edwards Awesome Customer Service. I have been with this company for 6 years.. And Gabe has gone above and beyond for me and all her customers. Very sweet lady
5 /5
angus williams Love this place. Staff is always friendly a CD very helpful and know their business well. They always get me the best quotes and pricing for my vehicles. Appreciate all that you do!
5 /5

19.Gibb Agency Insurance

Address: 13381 State Hwy 155, Tyler, TX 75703

(28) Clients Are Saying about:

Denise Hoyle Amanda was fantastic in helping our company get set up with insurance! I highly recommend her!!
5 /5
Dee Kirkpatrick Agent was very thorough and ran A couple of different companies in order to have comparisons to see difference in rates and companies.
4 /5