Tony And Luigis - Georgetown (TX)

3 /5 Kiyah: I think Ill continue to spend my money at Mandolas and Olive Garden. I just moved here and I was excited to try a new italian spot. Italian is my favorite cuisine. This place is passable and underwhelming when it comes to the food. Good portion sizes for the price but, lackluster in taste. I ordered for take out. The spaghetti bolognese was disappointing to say the least and wasnt good enough for me to force myself to finish it. Im not sure what seasoning they are using; maybe just salt and pepper, a little oregano? Not sure, regardless I wasnt impressed. The tiramasu was good. But why is the top wet? Isnt it supposed to be topped with cocoa powder instead of (what Im guessing is) chocolate syrup? **shrug** The staff was nice and my food came quick but, thats not enough for me to come back. MID.

5 /5 Rafael Santelises: Tony and Luigi’s is absolutely incredible. The food is consistently delicious, the portions are generous, and the atmosphere is warm and welcoming. The staff always goes above and beyond, making every visit feel special. Whether you’re craving authentic pasta, perfectly cooked entrées, or amazing desserts, this place never disappoints. Highly recommend definitely the best Italian spot around!

1 /5 Skylar Hartfiel: It hurts to write this review because this used to be my favorite restaurant in Georgetown. In fact, I previously left them a glowing review on Google about 8 months ago (screenshot below). But we had such a bad customer service experience that I feel it is necessary to write this review. I have been coming to Tony and Luigi’s for at least 7 or 8 years, and my family loved this place. The food is great, and I even got it catered on several occasions- graduations, baby showers, family events. The service was also impeccable. We usually got a server who was kind and sweet and told me that I looked just like her son. Fast forward to New Year’s Eve. We were excited when we realized the restaurant was open. I decided to take my fiancée and out of town in laws to the restaurant. Understandably, the place was pretty busy. No problem. We patiently waited for the server to come back and get our drink orders. Once she came back, enough time had passed that we were ready to also put in our food orders. When I mentioned we were ready to put in the food order, the server instantly became visibly irritated. Then I tried to place my usual order (that I’ve had here at least 20 times) a half pepperoni half cheese pizza on Alfredo sauce. The server rudely stated that “we don’t do that.” I calmly explained that this request was always accommodated with no issue. In response she snapped, “not today, we’re too busy for that.” I completely understand that it’s a holiday and the restaurant was busy. And I totally understand not being able to make the accommodation this time. But it was the manner and attitude with which the server delivered the message that made me feel small. She could have been polite about it, and there would not have been any issue whatsoever. We all could have enjoyed our meal and had a pleasant experience. To make matters worse, the manager came over to check in on us and had a poor attitude as well. At this point, we decided to leave the restaurant and find a bite to eat elsewhere. I am honestly hurt by this experience. This used to be my favorite restaurant in Georgetown, and somewhere we ate and got catered frequently. The servers were always super kind and I reciprocated with good tipping. But after this poor customer service experience, my family will not be back, and that truly makes me very sad.

4 /5 Taylor Paul: We got to try Tony and Luigis for an early dinner this evening! We have tempted to come on a weekend before, without a reservation, and there was a very long wait, so we booked ahead this time! The staff were all very friendly and helpful, and the service was super quick! My kids loved that they could draw on the paper tablecloth while waiting. We got the artichoke and pepper dip as our appetizer, and it wasnt our favorite. Although it tasted ok, its more of a soup consistency and not what we expected. I got Luigis Spicy Chicken Pasta and it was great! Its a huge portion and I got to take a lot of it home. My girls loved their spaghetti and pizza, and my husband enjoyed his caesar salad. We definitely want to come back again, there are so many items on the menu that sounds delicious!